Friday, December 21, 2012

Two schools of thought interpreting Bills' new lease

BY NICK ST. DENIS

The Buffalo Bills announced Friday they signed a new 10-year lease at Ralph Wilson Stadium, with a $400 million penalty if the team wanted to move out of town in the next seven years and a $29 million penalty to get out of the lease in the eighth year, according to the Associate Press and The Buffalo News.

After reading multiple reports and even more fan reaction via story comments and message boards posts, the new agreement, which also commits $130 million in stadium renovations, seems to have divided the fanbase on what the terms of the deal really mean. (photo: Eammon, Flickr)

There are two general schools of thought: a positive one and a negative one.

Positive thinking:

- It's a win simply because it guarantees the Bills stay in Buffalo for at least seven more years. The $400 million is enough to deter even a prospective owner to move the team. We'll worry about the rest later. Just enjoy it.

- The $130 million is a good thing because it will help preserve the Ralph while maintaining the atmosphere that has made it so endearing over the years.

- The $130 million means that the team/county/state is banking on Band-Aiding the Ralph while deciding on and executing an in-region move and/or a new stadium build. In fact, the Bills announced the creation of a "New Stadium Working Group" that will help keep the Bills in Buffalo.

- Everything else aside, seven years should be long enough for Los Angeles (or another potential moving destination), if it will in fact get a team soon, to have already scooped up another franchise.

Negative thinking:

- The seven-year aspect is questionable, as Ralph Wilson sadly might not outlive the lease, which would mean a new owner, given that Wilson himself doesn't sell before he passes, could have ample time to plan a move. Even if said owner doesn't make a move in time at the eighth year, he/she could use the next three to chart an escape.

- $130 million isn't enough to do much of anything with one of the rougher stadiums in the league, and the Band-Aid idea it just furthers the potential of a Bill-less Buffalo in a decade.

- Even if the Bills do stay in Buffalo, the stadium and temporary-fix atmosphere will continue to repel a better product on the field and a better fan experience.

Follow Nick @NickStDenis
Follow AFC East Daily @AFCEastDaily